Lenders face a tough choice in 2025: Build AI in-house or buy/outsource. Shrinking margins, rising compliance costs, and borrower demands for faster, digital experiences leave Independent Mortgage Bankers (IMBs) at a crossroads. Here’s the bottom line:
- Building AI in-house is expensive, time-consuming, and requires specialized talent (often costing $200K+ per hire)[17]. Most projects take 18–36 months and only 15% succeed due to talent gaps, data issues, and strategic misalignment[16].
- Buying AI solutions offers faster implementation (3–8 months)[18], higher success rates (~90%)[19], and measurable benefits like 15–25% higher lead conversion rates and reduced loan officer workloads.
For IMBs already struggling with an average loss of $28 per loan in Q1 2025, the decision has never been more urgent. And, waiting isn’t an option.
Let’s Start with the Bottom Line: Sunk Cost or Compounding Investment?
Just as in upgrading a home, you choose the investments that build equity over the fixes that never pay you back. The same principle applies to your business.
Building tech in‑house leads to millions in sunk costs on projects that take 18 to 36 months and succeed less than 30% of the time. On the other hand, outsourcing to AI experts ensures speed, proven execution, and access to specialized talent without the overhead.
The smarter path is to implement AI solutions that cut costs and create balance‑sheet assets in the form of intellectual property.
(Shameless plug) That’s the difference in partnering with ThoughtFocus Build. We underwrite the build, absorb the upfront risk, and can contractually guarantee profitability from day one.
The Build or Buy Decision for IMBs
The Build vs. Buy Question
With slim margins and rising costs, IMBs are faced with a critical decision: build custom AI solutions or purchase pre-built platforms? Developing AI in-house often requires significant upfront investments, access to highly specialized talent, and extended timelines. These projects frequently go over budget and risk falling out of sync with rapidly changing market conditions. For many IMBs, these constraints make internal development a daunting prospect.
On the other hand, buying ready-to-deploy AI solutions offers the advantage of immediate implementation and quicker returns. However, concerns remain. Many IMBs worry that adopting off-the-shelf platforms could limit their ability to stand out in a competitive market or lock them into systems that don’t fully meet their unique needs.
The stakes are high. According to MBA data, 58 percent of mortgage companies in their sample are currently profitable, leaving 42 percent still struggling to break even[3]. For lenders, making the right choice between building or buying AI could mean the difference between gaining operational efficiency and falling further behind competitors who are using AI to streamline their processes and capture more market share.
As AI adoption accelerates across the mortgage industry, the decision to build or buy is becoming increasingly urgent. The clock is ticking, and IMBs must act swiftly to position themselves for success in this rapidly evolving landscape.
Why Building AI In-House Fails Most Lenders
The Knowledge Gap: From IT to AI Expertise
The mortgage industry’s growing reliance on AI has revealed a major roadblock: a significant gap in expertise. Many lenders mistakenly assume that traditional IT skills will seamlessly translate to AI development, but the reality is far more complex. AI development demands a completely different set of skills, and this disconnect often causes projects to stumble before they even get off the ground. One of the biggest hurdles is the shortage of AI talent. Building effective AI systems requires more than just software developers – it calls for data scientists, machine learning engineers, and AI specialists who not only understand the technical intricacies of artificial intelligence but also the regulatory landscape unique to mortgage lending. This talent gap often delays, or outright derails, projects [5].
The challenge becomes even more daunting when you factor in the specific needs of the mortgage industry. AI systems here must navigate fair lending regulations, handle sensitive customer data, and integrate with outdated systems. Michael Akinwumi, Chief AI Officer at the National Fair Housing Alliance, puts it succinctly:
“AI is like a mirror that reflects what is right in front of it, so all it can do is to reflect the patterns of marginalization that you have in the data” [6].
This highlights why general AI developers aren’t enough. Mortgage lenders need experts who can balance technical know-how with compliance requirements to reduce risks like discriminatory outcomes. Without this specialized expertise, delays pile up, costs soar, and projects often fail to meet expectations.
Hidden Costs and Long Timelines
Building AI in-house isn’t just about technical challenges – it also comes with hidden costs and drawn-out timelines that can derail even the most well-intentioned projects. These initiatives often start as seemingly manageable investments but quickly spiral into costly endeavors with uncertain payoffs [5]. One major issue is poor data quality, which can significantly extend development timelines. Many financial institutions struggle with this, leading to unreliable AI models and wasted resources [5].
Timelines for in-house projects frequently exceed initial estimates. During these delays, market conditions shift, regulations evolve, and borrower expectations change, leaving custom solutions outdated before they’re even fully deployed. Meanwhile, the financial services sector is expected to pour $97 billion into AI by 2027 [6]. A large portion of this spending on internal projects risks being wasted due to unforeseen expenses and technical roadblocks.
Integration and Scalability Problems
Even when lenders manage to develop functional AI solutions, the next challenge is often even harder: integrating these systems with their existing infrastructure. Many lenders still rely on decades-old legacy systems that don’t play well with modern AI technologies [5]. Whether it’s loan origination platforms or compliance systems, these outdated setups make integration a costly and time-consuming process, often requiring custom APIs or middleware.
Scalability is another stumbling block. Custom-built AI solutions might work well during initial testing but often falter under real-world demands. Scaling these systems to handle higher volumes or more complex scenarios can require expensive re-architecture and additional development.
Algorithmic bias adds another layer of complexity. As Syeed Mansur, CEO of GreenLyne, cautions:
“We need to take those cues from the biotech industry, not from the IT industry. If we go fast and break things, we end up breaking someone’s financial life” [6].
This means lenders must rigorously test their AI systems across diverse borrower profiles and loan scenarios before deploying them widely, further increasing costs and timelines. The combination of integration headaches, scalability challenges, and strict compliance requirements often results in custom AI projects falling short of expectations. For lenders already dealing with tight margins and operational hurdles, these setbacks can significantly weaken their competitive edge.
How AI-Powered Buying Has Changed the Game
From Rigid Platforms to Flexible AI Solutions
Building AI systems in-house can be a daunting task, but AI-powered buying offers a much smoother alternative. Older platforms often forced lenders to adapt their workflows to rigid systems, disrupting their processes. In contrast, today’s AI platforms are modular and integrate easily with tools like CRMs, loan origination systems, and marketing software through robust APIs. This means lenders can maintain their unique workflows while benefiting from AI-driven efficiencies. These platforms continuously learn from user interactions, fine-tuning their performance to align with each lender’s underwriting criteria, branding, and customer engagement strategies.
Speed Without Losing Differentiation
AI-powered solutions bring speed and efficiency without compromising what makes a lender stand out. Deployment is quick, with results often seen within 30-60 days and full ROI typically achieved within a year [8]. This fast impact is driven by automation of manual tasks, improved lead management, and better borrower experiences.
For example, lenders using AI have seen their lead conversion rates rise from the industry average of 3% to an impressive 8-12% [10]. On top of that, automation saves loan officers 10-15 hours each week, freeing them up to focus on building relationships and closing deals rather than handling repetitive administrative tasks. These are not just theoretical gains – they’re real, measurable outcomes that have transformed the way lenders operate.
Success Stories from the Industry
Take Fello, for example. In July 2025, the company revealed that lenders using its AI-powered mortgage prospecting platform boosted conversion rates from 3% to 8-12% while saving loan officers 10-15 hours a week. By harnessing machine learning, natural language processing, and predictive analytics, Fello’s platform reactivated dormant leads and optimized prospect engagement, uncovering over $1 billion in untapped business opportunities [10].
Another standout example is Novaprime’s Loan Intelligence solution, which earned recognition in July 2025 for its AI-driven mortgage quality control. This platform automated data and document integrity checks, reducing errors and streamlining workflows. Its modular design enabled real-time compliance checks and routed exceptions directly to human reviewers, improving both speed and accuracy [11].
The broader impact of AI is clear. Leading mortgage originators now use AI platforms to create underwriter-ready loan files in under 10 minutes – a task that previously took hours or even days [7]. These examples highlight how AI-powered buying delivers immediate and measurable benefits. Unlike the lengthy and uncertain process of building AI internally, these solutions provide predictable outcomes, allowing lenders to focus on what matters most: serving borrowers and growing their business.
Comparing ROI: Build vs. Buy vs. AI-Powered Buy
Key ROI Drivers
When it comes to ROI in mortgage lending, speed, deployment success rates, and measurable business outcomes are the heavy hitters. These metrics explain why the old debate – whether to build in-house or buy off-the-shelf – has shifted toward partnering with specialized AI providers.
Speed is a game-changer. Developing AI internally can take anywhere from 18 to 36 months (or more), while external providers can roll out solutions in just 3 to 8 months[12]. This faster timeline means lenders can capitalize on market opportunities well before competitors slog through lengthy in-house development cycles.
Then there’s the success rate. Internal AI projects have a deployment success rate of only around 30%, compared to an impressive 90% with external AI providers[12]. This difference comes down to the expertise and ready-to-go infrastructure that specialized providers bring to the table.
The results speak for themselves. Companies that implement AI-driven lead management systems within 6 to 8 months have reported 15–25% improvements in lead conversion rates. In some cases, those gains have soared to as high as 46%, alongside a 15% increase in closings from existing leads[12].
Build vs. AI-Powered Buy Table
The numbers make a strong case for why AI-powered buying is the smarter move:
| Factor | Build In-House | AI-Powered Buy |
|---|---|---|
| Timeline | 18–36+ months | 3–8 months |
| Success Rate | ~30% successful deployment | ~90% successful deployment |
| Lead Conversion Impact | Not measurable until deployment | 15–25% improvement (up to 46% in some cases) |
These comparisons highlight the advantages of AI-powered solutions. Faster rollouts, higher success rates, and measurable improvements in lead conversions all translate to reduced opportunity costs and a stronger competitive edge. In today’s fast-moving, AI-driven mortgage market, every month saved can make a significant difference.
sbb-itb-5f0736d
Q&AI: AI-Driven Platforms Modernize Mortgages
Conclusion: AI Has Changed the Lender Playbook
AI has reshaped how lenders make technology decisions, challenging the old approach of building everything in-house. For most IMBs, this strategy no longer makes financial or strategic sense. Developing in-house solutions requires an upfront investment of around $750,000 and takes about eight months to show results. In contrast, AI-powered tools deliver measurable benefits much faster – boosting conversion rates by 15–25% and achieving full ROI in just 90 days [15].
Loan officers using AI-driven platforms also gain back 10–15 hours each week, giving them a significant edge over competitors [10].
Modern AI solutions solve the traditional hurdles of in-house development by offering flexibility, built-in compliance frameworks, and automatic regulatory updates. These features not only minimize risk but also speed up results, making AI a perfect fit for the specific needs of IMBs. With 55% of lenders planning to start AI trials or rollouts by 2025 [9], the opportunity to gain a first-mover advantage is quickly slipping away – early adopters are already reaping the rewards.
Companies like ThoughtFocus Build are leading the charge by offering hybrid AI-human workforce solutions that address in-house limitations. Their approach delivers immediate ROI while ensuring long-term competitive benefits. Now is the time to embrace AI and take the lead in this transformation.
Why spend time and resources building in-house when ready-to-deploy AI solutions are available? Partnering with proven AI tools can unlock the operational efficiency and market edge your business needs to thrive in 2025 and beyond.
FAQs
What are the main benefits of buying pre-built AI solutions instead of building them in-house for Independent Mortgage Bankers (IMBs)?
Buying pre-built AI solutions offers quick implementation and instant benefits, giving Independent Mortgage Bankers (IMBs) the chance to see a return on investment (ROI) much sooner than the often lengthy and expensive process of developing AI in-house. Building custom AI systems can cost millions upfront, stretch timelines significantly, and carry a high risk of failure. Many such projects exceed budgets or face challenges when scaling.
On the other hand, modern AI platforms are built with lenders in mind, offering seamless integration and flexibility without compromising on the ability to stand out. By opting for pre-built solutions, IMBs can prioritize enhancing borrower experiences, staying compliant, and streamlining operations – without the financial and operational risks tied to in-house development.
How can IMBs choose AI solutions that meet regulatory requirements and adapt to their specific needs?
To ensure that AI tools align with regulatory standards and meet specific operational needs, IMBs should team up with vendors who emphasize compliance, transparency, and flexibility. It’s essential to choose providers with a history of meeting industry benchmarks and consistently updating their solutions to reflect evolving regulations.
It’s also wise to opt for AI systems that include auditability and explainability features. These capabilities are crucial for maintaining regulatory compliance and tailoring the technology to fit your workflow. By concentrating on these aspects, IMBs can adopt AI solutions that improve efficiency while staying within the bounds of compliance.
What should IMBs look for in an AI partner to ensure strong ROI and stay ahead in the mortgage industry?
When choosing an AI partner, Independent Mortgage Banks (IMBs) should zero in on a few critical areas to ensure they get the most out of their investment and stay ahead in the market. One of the top priorities is integration readiness – your AI system should blend effortlessly with existing tools and workflows to avoid unnecessary disruptions or expenses.
Another key factor is compliance expertise. The platform must align with evolving regulatory standards to keep your operations on the right side of the law. Beyond that, focus on partners with a proven history of delivering real ROI – look for measurable results like enhanced borrower experiences, quicker processing times, and cost savings.
Finally, choose solutions that are scalable and flexible enough to adapt to market shifts without requiring constant updates or replacements. By selecting an AI partner that checks all these boxes, IMBs can gain immediate advantages while setting themselves up for long-term success.